Noah (angelbob) wrote,
Noah
angelbob

Y'know, I realized something. The argument against gay marriage that goes "if we let gays marry, soon we'll have to let houseplants, dogs, hubcaps, poor people and other undesirables marry" is a little weird, and not just for the obvious reasons.

Because nobody seems to extend that to, say, murder, assault, burglary and so on. There's too obvious a reason that it doesn't work, and it's the same answer people give to the pedophilia thing -- there are other perfectly good reasons that that's already a crime, so you don't have to worry about them marrying.

So the argument actually runs, "if we can no longer arbitrarily forbid you to marry someone of your own gender, then soon we'll have to stop arbitrarily forbidding you to marry *anybody*, and before long we'll have to have reasons for all *sorts* of laws, and society as we know it will collapse."

In other words, "we can't require laws to have *reasons*, because that way lies anarchy!"
Subscribe

  • Welp, that's it.

    The last person I knew on here is moving over to DreamWidth. When I load my friends list (without her) I literally get one private post from me and…

  • Moved all my RSS feeds over...

    It looks like DreamWidth also supports creating unlimited RSS feeds for various stuff... I've moved all mine over. Okay, *now* my friends list looks…

  • Setting up DreamWidth...

    I now have noahgibbs.dreamwidth.org. This same userid already belongs to somebody else who has no posts and doesn't otherwise resemble me. Still…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 12 comments

  • Welp, that's it.

    The last person I knew on here is moving over to DreamWidth. When I load my friends list (without her) I literally get one private post from me and…

  • Moved all my RSS feeds over...

    It looks like DreamWidth also supports creating unlimited RSS feeds for various stuff... I've moved all mine over. Okay, *now* my friends list looks…

  • Setting up DreamWidth...

    I now have noahgibbs.dreamwidth.org. This same userid already belongs to somebody else who has no posts and doesn't otherwise resemble me. Still…